Covid-19 test and trace system ‘failure cost lives’ – campaigners
The test and trace system deployed during the Covid-19 pandemic was an “abject failure”, campaigners have said.
It comes as Baroness Heather Hallett, chairwoman of the UK Covid-19 Public Inquiry, publishes her latest report on Thursday on the measures taken to prevent the spread of the virus.
Speaking ahead of the publication of the report, the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK group said: “The UK’s test and trace system was an abject failure that cost lives.
“Thursday’s report must be honest about those failures and give bereaved families the truth about why their loved ones were left unprotected.
“It must hold those responsible to account and set out what needs to change so we are prepared for the next crisis.”
At the start of the pandemic in January 2020, health leaders said risk to the UK population was “very low” and later that month that “UK public health measures are world-leading and our excellent NHS is well prepared to manage and treat new diseases”.
As the situation unfolded, the World Health Organisation (WHO) declared the the outbreak was a “public health emergency of international concern” and officials raised the risk level in the UK from low to moderate.
The Government, NHS and Public Health England (PHE) issued guidance to the public, announced plans for a new surveillance system to “prepare for and prevent wider transmission of the virus” and stepped up testing capacity.
In March of 2020, the Government announced the nation was moving out of the “contain” phase of the virus and on to the “delay” phase as the threat level raised again from moderate to high.
This meant the limited contact tracing that had been happening when a case was identified stopped, with officials claiming that wider spread in the population meant it was “no longer the most useful strategy”.
As of February 2020, PHE was only equipped to deal with five new cases a week and the associated isolation of 800 contacts.
Due to limited capacity, active contact tracing was directed at high-risk settings such as care homes and hospitals.
In the run-up to the first national lockdown in March 2020, and as WHO declared the outbreak a pandemic, a number of additional measures were introduced including stay at home guidance for people with symptoms and new social distancing measures.
WHO urged countries to “test, test, test”, but in the UK officials decided to prioritise tests for hospital staff and patients.
As schools shut their doors on pupils and entertainment, leisure and hospitality businesses closed, more measures were announced to help the most vulnerable shield themselves from the virus.
On March 23, 2020, the first national lockdown was imposed, with then prime minister Boris Johnson telling people: “From this evening I must give the British people a very simple instruction – you must stay at home.”
Days later, the Government announced a “five pillar” strategy to scale up testing, with former health secretary Matt Hancock pledging 100,000 tests a day would available by May 2020.
So-called “lighthouse labs” were launched to increase the number of tests that could be carried out each day.
In April 2020, Mr Hancock announced a test, track and trace programme in England including large-scale recruitment for contact tracers and the development of a new contact tracing app.
Baroness Dido Harding was appointed lead for NHS Test and Trace, which was launched in May, aiming to give anyone with Covid-19 symptoms access to a test. If they tested positive their recent contacts were advised to isolate.
Testing was therefore scaled up over time, eventually leading to drive-though test centres and postal tests made available across the population.
The tracing programme was telephone-based at first and the app was released in September of 2020, after being beset by a number of technical problems in its development and pilot phase.
Millions downloaded the NHS Covid-19 app, which included a number of features including getting alerts to let someone know if they have been near a person who had tested positive, and general advice about the virus.
While the app drew criticism for functionality, a paper published in the journal Nature Communications, estimated the app’s contact tracing function alone helped to avert one million cases of the virus, saving almost 10,000 lives.
In September 2020, people in England were be required by law to self-isolate if they tested positive or are contacted by NHS Test and Trace.
Support was made available for people on low incomes who were unable to work while self-isolating through the £500 Test and Trace Support Payment.
Lady Harding has previously told the Covid inquiry that if the government had provided more support for people to self-isolate during the pandemic, more lives would have been saved.
She added that former prime minister Rishi Sunak – then chancellor – would not budge on proposals to pay people more to isolate.
Meanwhile the probe also heard that former prime minister Boris Johnson favoured an “authoritarian approach” to punishing people who failed to isolate during the pandemic.
Diary entries from the Government’s then-chief scientific adviser Lord Patrick Vallance were also scrutinised by the inquiry.
A January 2021 note by Lord Vallance said: “PM says: ‘We haven’t been ruthless enough. We need to force more isolation. I favour a more authoritarian approach’.”
A separate Public Accounts Committee report, published in October 2021, concluded that NHS Test and Trace had “not achieved its main objective to help break chains of Covid-19 transmission and enable people to return towards a more normal way of life”.
By June 2021, the service had sent out 691 million lateral flow tests, but results had been registered for 14% of them, the report stated.
A few months into the crisis, PHE was axed following criticism of its performance during the pandemic.
A new body, the National Institute for Health Protection, took on some PHE’s existing responsibilities along with the NHS Test and Trace programme and the work of the Joint Biosecurity Centre.
This evolved into the UK Health Security Agency, which is now responsible for public health in England alongside the and the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities.
The inquiry may also touch on ex-MP Owen Paterson’s involvement with a company awarded a contract to supply millions of Covid tests.
Mr Paterson quit as an MP in 2021 after he was found to have breached rules on paid advocacy when he lobbied ministers on behalf of Randox.
Clare Fletcher, a solicitor from Broudie Jackson Canter, which represents more than 7,000 families from Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK, said: “Test and trace was a shambolic and chaotic system that led to avoidable loss of many lives despite the eyewatering sums of taxpayers’ money that were injected into the system.
“Our clients hope the chair confirms what many believe – it was fatally flawed and made many private firms and contractors rich, while too many innocent lives were lost.
“We call on the chair to recognise the true extent of the impact this had on so many families and agree to binding recommendations to ensure the same tragedies never happen again.”
Published: by Radio NewsHub